What a House Is Worth

I price things for a living. A house, I learned, is bought with the heart as much as the numbers.

A yellow beach house with white railings and palm trees

I’ve spent my career putting a price on things. Companies, deals, the cost buried in the fine print where no one thinks to look. So, when I walked through a North Carolina beach house in the spring of 2021, and the woman selling it mentioned she wanted to start a new life somewhere else, I did what I do. I offered her seven thousand dollars for all the furniture in the house.

She countered at thirty thousand, which was surely a discount on what it had cost her, and I understood that. But I also knew most of it would be at the donation center the day my own furniture arrived, so I held firm. In the end she took my offer but she wasn’t happy about it. She had planned to drive across the country in her new RV and that’s where her planning stopped. A motivated seller without a plan is how a deal like that gets made.

A bright living room with a white sectional

I needed the house ready to go, not ready later. My company had just acquired another company nearby, and I would be living there half of the time.

In the middle of the pandemic frenzy nothing could be delivered; an April sofa order would arrive nine months later, if at all. That seven thousand dollars bought two things I couldn’t get any other way, that year at least. A house I could live in the day I got the keys.

And, buried in a great deal of junk, a handful of pieces that were well made: a master bedroom set, the dining furniture, solid and heavy and better than anything I could have ordered in a hurry. Those alone would have cost more than I paid for everything. I kept them, worked them into the design, and donated the rest as my new pieces arrived.

One urgent cost caught me off guard. I had always planned to paint, since every room was its own loud color. I’d not planned to refinish every floor in the house the month I moved in. During the showings we smelled nothing. The morning the keys were mine, all I could smell was years of cat and dog soaked into the subfloor; whatever they had done for the open house, the right air freshener combined with the windows thrown wide, had held the smell down just long enough for a clean pass. The reality is, I still would have bought the house, I simply would have negotiated the floor refinishing into the price. So the nineties honey oak finish went matte and dark sooner than I meant it to, the carpet went to the curb, and the house came to smell of salt and fresh paint instead.